Demand Letter Drafter
After completing medical treatment or reaching maximum medical improvement, when you have all damage figures ready.
A demand letter is usually the first formal step toward resolving a personal injury claim without litigation — and its quality directly shapes the settlement offer that comes back. A vague, thinly documented demand invites a lowball response; a tightly argued one with itemized damages signals that you are trial-ready and have done the work.
This is a task Claude handles well. Give it the liability facts, the treatment history, and your damage figures, and it returns a structured, persuasive letter that ties each injury to the incident and supports every dollar of the demand. You stay in control of strategy and numbers; Claude produces the first draft so your time goes to refining the argument rather than assembling boilerplate.
Use the prompt below as a starting point. Replace the bracketed placeholders with your case specifics, then review and adapt the output to your jurisdiction and your client. Claude's draft is attorney work product to refine — not legal advice, and not a finished letter to send unreviewed.
The Prompt
Draft a demand letter for the following personal injury case: Incident type: [e.g., auto accident, slip and fall, medical malpractice] Date of incident: [DATE] Liability facts: [DESCRIBE HOW THE DEFENDANT WAS AT FAULT] Injuries sustained: [LIST ALL INJURIES] Medical treatment received: [SUMMARIZE TREATMENT] Medical expenses to date: [TOTAL AND BREAKDOWN] Lost wages: [AMOUNT AND CALCULATION BASIS] Other economic damages: [e.g., property damage, out-of-pocket costs] Pain and suffering factors: [DESCRIBE IMPACT ON DAILY LIFE] Demand amount: [YOUR TARGET] Insurance carrier and claim number: [DETAILS] Structure the letter as follows: 1. Introduction identifying parties and the incident 2. Detailed liability analysis with specific negligent acts 3. Injury narrative — connect the incident to each injury 4. Itemized damages with supporting calculations 5. Pain and suffering argument with specific life impacts 6. Demand amount with response deadline (30 days) 7. Reservation of rights to file suit
Example Output
A 3-5 page demand letter with itemized damages table, liability analysis citing specific negligent conduct, and a persuasive pain and suffering narrative.
Illustrative example — names, figures, and facts are fictional.
[Law Firm Letterhead] October 14, 2026 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL & EMAIL Ms. Karen Doyle, Senior Claims Adjuster Meridian Casualty Insurance Co. Claim No. MC-2026-44817 Re: Claimant: Daniel Ruiz | Date of Loss: March 3, 2026 Dear Ms. Doyle: This firm represents Daniel Ruiz for injuries sustained in the March 3, 2026 rear-end collision caused by your insured, Mr. Thomas Vael. Liability is not in serious dispute: Mr. Vael struck Mr. Ruiz's stationary vehicle at the I-35 exit ramp, and the police report (No. 26-10293) cites him for failure to control speed. INJURIES & TREATMENT As a direct result of the collision, Mr. Ruiz suffered a C5-C6 disc herniation, cervical radiculopathy, and lumbar strain. He completed 42 physical-therapy visits and underwent a C5-C6 epidural steroid injection on May 9, 2026, reaching maximum medical improvement on August 1, 2026. ITEMIZED DAMAGES Emergency & imaging (Mercy Regional) ......... $ 8,420 Orthopedic & pain management ................. $ 12,650 Physical therapy (42 visits) ................. $ 6,930 Epidural steroid injection ................... $ 4,100 Lost wages (6 weeks @ $1,540/wk) ............. $ 9,240 -------------------------------------------------------- Economic damages ............................. $ 41,340 PAIN AND SUFFERING Mr. Ruiz, a 38-year-old warehouse supervisor, could not lift his infant daughter for nearly three months and continues to experience numbness in his dominant hand, limiting both his work and his role at home. DEMAND Based on the foregoing, demand is hereby made in the amount of $145,000 in full settlement of this claim. This offer remains open for thirty (30) days, after which we are prepared to file suit. All rights are expressly reserved. Sincerely, [Attorney Name], Esq.
Tips
- •Include specific dollar amounts for every damage category — vague demands get lowball responses.
- •Reference the adjuster by name and claim number in the opening paragraph.
- •Attach a damages summary spreadsheet as an exhibit.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should I send a demand letter in a personal injury case?
Generally after your client reaches maximum medical improvement (MMI) and you have final figures for medical specials, lost wages, and other economic damages. Demanding too early — before the full extent of the injuries is known — risks undervaluing the claim. The prompt asks for treatment status precisely so the letter reflects a complete damages picture.
Will Claude's demand letter be ready to send as-is?
No. Treat the output as a strong first draft. Verify every figure against the file, confirm the liability narrative matches the record, tailor the tone to the specific adjuster, and adjust for your jurisdiction before sending. The attorney remains responsible for the final letter.
How do I get the most persuasive output?
Be specific. Provide concrete liability facts, an itemized damages breakdown with exact dollar amounts, and detailed pain-and-suffering impacts on daily life. Vague inputs produce generic letters; precise inputs produce a letter an adjuster takes seriously.
Is it ethical to use AI to draft a demand letter?
Yes, when done responsibly. ABA Formal Opinion 512 permits AI use in legal work provided the lawyer supervises the output, protects client confidentiality, and verifies accuracy. Avoid pasting privileged client identifiers into consumer AI tools without appropriate data protections, and always review the draft before it leaves your office.
Related Prompts
Get New Prompts Like This Every Week
Join the free Claude for Lawyers newsletter — weekly prompts, tutorials, and practice-specific guides.